Friday, June 26, 2015

Can You Separate The Author From Their Book?

There's a reason why I don't interact with many authors. (Actually, a couple, but we won't get into the other one.) The reason is that I'm terrified I'm going to find an author whose writing I love but, when I sit down and read a interview…I have problems (to put it lightly) with them. (This is also why I don't visit many author blogs and/or twitter feeds.)

Some time back I was going to read Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card. In preparation for that, I poked around on the internet to see what I could find out about the book. Like I usually do with old and/or well known books. Biggest mistake ever, because instead of finding anything about the book, I found an interview that Card gave. (You're happier not knowing, trust me. But if you're curious, they're not difficult to find.)

On a slightly unrelated note, I just recently heard talk about this actor that I like. I've seen him in several things and always love his characters and thought he was a really cool guy. Now I find out he is a misogynist and a racist. Truthfully, I'm not sure what to do with that. (I'm kind of thinking 'pretend I never saw it but don't support him ever again'. Hopefully I'll still be able to re-watch on of my favorite shows that he's on.)

If it's just a case of disagreeing with them, I do fine. I mean, different ideas make the world go around and all that, right? But, what happens when an author says something that you just disagree with on every level? My question is, can you still read their book? Do you avoid authors to avoid this problem?

I gotta admit, some time back I was searching around the net for something and found a Q&A type forum with my favorite author. Against my better judgment, I read it. You know, I think his answers actually made me like him more. Humor and a real down-to-earth personality came through during this. (He also totally endeared himself to me when asked how he creates such strong women and his answer was basically 'I create characters. The fact that they're women is irrelevant.') There's also another author whose blog I visited and loved before even knowing she was an author. (And I love her book, too.)

So, what do you do? Share with me. Do you avoid most authors? Can you separate authors from their books? Honestly, I don't think I can.

Comments (4)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I find that I'm absolutely horrible at separating the author from his/her work. I wrote a similar post to this, I'm not sure if you've read it, but overall I wrote about my worries over not being able to enjoy the sequel to Dorothy Must Die due to the fact that I read a tweet by the author that straight out supported Kathleen Hale's actions. At the time I wrote the said post I was convinced I can put this aside and read the book but when the reviews started to come and a fair share of them was negative I thought: thank god, now I don't have to worry anymore because it sound sucky so I have an actual reason not to buy the book. And I deleted the book from my TBR smiling. So I don't think I can either. I can easily separate actors and singers from their work, though. I think that's because even though I have to see and hear them a book feels more... personal than a movie can ever be. About a song, I guess those can be pretty personal as well but most artists I dislike don't have personal songs so no problem there.
Great discussion as always, Amy. :)
My recent post Trish Doller - The Devil You Know
1 reply · active 508 weeks ago
I think I missed that post of yours, Veronika. In fact, I missed most of the stuff with Kathleen Hale until just recently I finally got curious enough to find out what, exactly, happened. I can totally understand not really wanting to read a book where the author agreed with or supported what Hale did. I think for me the difference between books and actors is that I usually like a specific character the actor plays but I'm seldom a fan of the actors. Singers are a little closer to authors for me, especially if they write their own songs. You're right about books feeling more personal.
It's definitely complicated...I'm constantly terrified that's going to happen with one of the authors I loved. I finally started following Tamora Pierce, Robin McKinley, and Kristin Cashore which so far hasn't been a bad idea (although there was some Tumblr controversy with Tammy, but she gave a whole-heartedly sincere and quick apology). But it definitely...I just don't want to know. I really don't. I tend to only find about said things when I get on twitter so I spend months not going on it because it feels like a snake pit of negativity and hatred and ughhh. But then on the flip side...if I loved a work it's not like I don't love it any more! (Although it definitely tamps down on my happiness about loving it). But then by actively avoiding to know things does that mean I support it by being ignorant? I DON'T KNOW. And it makes my head hurt haha
My recent post Unpopular Opinions Tag
1 reply · active 505 weeks ago
You're definitely right about it being complicated. Even if the author says something I can't stand, it's not like I can just quit liking a book of theirs. This is why I want to know all the bad stuff about them before ever picking up the book so I never pick it up. And now you've really giving me something to think about by avoiding knowing what the authors say. (And it's not particularly comfortable thoughts, which is good.) I've yet to follow any authors on twitter, though there are some I think I'd like too. But I'm just very lazy when it comes to twitter and totally don't interact as much as I should.

Post a new comment

Comments by