Lately I've been hearing a lot from people how they don't read reviews for a book they're planning on reading. In a way, I can understand that. (Especially when it comes to unmarked spoilers.) Some people say they're worried about plagiarism and unintentionally copying another review - while others are more concerned about coloring their thoughts on the books.
Personally, I really like reading reviews of books I'm interested in. Ever since I found Goodreads years ago, I've been using it to check what others have to say about the book. Sometimes I just quickly scan the first few reviews and if there's a common thread (such as the book needing an editor) I'll probably just give it a pass. However, sometimes I get really in depth reading the reviews there.
I like reading low rated reviews. One or two stars. For me, they're the most helpful because these are people (unlike what I always think of when I see a three star review) that were passionate about the book. But, unlike the fans that gush over a five star read, it seems like you get more information from the people that disliked the book. It seems like one and two star reviews make a real effort to tell you why the book didn't work for them and why it might work for someone else.
Once, I even decided to read a book based solely on a single one star review at Goodreads. The way the person described the book, everything they had problems with, made it sound like exactly my kind of book. While it could have been better, I did wind up liking it to the tune of three stars.
Then there's the bloggers whose reviews I just love to read. I've found some great books that way!
How about you? Do you read reviews if it's a book you want to read? Do you prefer reading low rated reviews or high rated ones?
Friday, June 5, 2015
Comments (2)

Sort by: Date Rating Last Activity
Loading comments...
Comments by IntenseDebate
Posting anonymously.
Reading Reviews Before Reading The Book?
2015-06-05T09:30:00-05:00
Unknown
Discuss|
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
mithrril 23p · 518 weeks ago
It's for all of the reasons you mentioned. I don't want spoilers, even if it's something small. And I don't want people's opinions to flavor mine before I even start. I do read reviews immediately after I finish a book though.
Reviews are still important for readers though because I'm sure there are tons of people like you who do read reviews to find out if they want to try a book. And just the fact that there are reviews will draw attention to books that you didn't know about. I also will occasionally read reviews ahead of time if it's something I'm on the fence about and then I appreciate 1 star reviews just as much as you. It's good to see people who are critical.
My recent post Award – Beautiful Blogger Award
AmyAelleah 80p · 518 weeks ago
Totally agree with you on reading reviews as soon as I finish a book. I love doing that. Sometimes they help me solidify my thoughts on a book and other times I'll go 'I didn't think of that'. And then sometimes it's just a case of loving to see different/same opinions.
I'll be looking through reviews on a blog and the cover of a book I'd never heard of before will catch my attention. It's always so much fun for me to find books my co-bloggers liked that sounds like something I'd enjoy. Also, I love reading their reviews on books I've read. If it's been awhile since I read the book, it can sometimes make me want to re-read it. Or finally continue the series.