Monday, April 7, 2014

Information: Too Much vs Too Little

Ideally, I'm sure, we all have that perfect amount of information we like in the books we read. For me, I like to see everyone plainly, have a good idea of what the characters look like in my mind, and a pretty clear picture of the location. Just enough that I can see it, but still use my imagination for it. I don't know about anyone else, but I seldom find that amount of description in the books.

So, my question this week is: if you had to choose between getting a lot of information about the area - full description of everything - and not even knowing the color of the character's hair - in other words, very little description of anything - which would you rather have?

For me, I'd actually prefer everything be over-described than barely having any descriptions and information.

I think this comes from all the fantasy books I read. In most of them, it's nearly a requirement that everything be described to death - sometimes quite literally. I will add, I'm not a very proper reader, in that I usually still go with my own ideas and impressions as opposed to what the author says. Which is why I like having a description, of the characters especially, right when they are first introduced.

What do you think?

Comments (2)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
It would be hard to chose between the two. I just finished a book that had way to much detail (Magic Under Glass) and it ruined the story for me. On the other hand, a book that doesn't have enough details makes for a poor story.
Oh, that sucks that all that detail ruined the book for you. I guess I was making a choice between the lesser of two evils. I have been known to gather the gist of the descriptions and then skim the rest when they go on forever.

I'm glad to know Magic Under Glass is so description heavy, as it a book I've been quite curious about for quite awhile. At least now, if I read it, I'll have an idea what to expect.

Post a new comment

Comments by