Sunday, April 12, 2015

My Eight Favorite 'Once' Characters (+ Retellings)

Thank you so much The Book Rat & A Backwards Story for hosting this.

I don't usually post on the weekends, but I wanted to do a couple of special Fairy Tale Fortnight posts. (And I thought that because they're non-bookish - at least, mostly - that the weekend would be perfect to post them. Besides, my week is filled!)

Originally this post was going to be about the fairy tale shows I've seen. (All two of them.) But, upon rewatching Once Upon a Time... well, let's just say, that changed.


I know you're asking 'why eight?' No, the fact that there are eight humans on that picture is just a coincidence. I chose eight because after that, things get progressively less neat and clearly defined. I just will have to face facts that I have eight favorites and everyone else. (Though I do have a couple of 'least favorites' but we won't talk about them.) Not exactly in order, but I do like the person at the top of the list more than the one at the bottom.

Ruby/Red Riding Hood

Retellings that feature Little Red Riding Hood:
Sisters RedPrincess of the Silver WoodsA Tale of Red Riding Hood

Regina Mills/The Evil Queen

Retellings that feature The Evil Queen:
Fairest of AllDewitched #1Fairest

Jefferson/Mad Hatter

Retellings that feature the Mad Hatter:
HatterThe Looking Glass WarsAlice in the Country of Hearts

Mulan

Retellings that feature Mulan:

Killian Jones/Captain Hook

Retellings that feature Captain Hook:
Captain James Hook and the Curse of Peter PanHook & JillAlias Hook

Dr. Whale/Victor Frankenstein

Retellings that feature Dr. Frankenstein:

Mr. Gold/Rumplestiltskin

Retellings that feature Rumplestiltskin:
RumplestiltskinThe Crimson ThreadA Curse as Dark as Gold

Belle French

Retellings that feature Belle:
Cruel BeautyOf Beast and BeautyBeauty and the Beast


Notes about my choices: I am left unsure at the end of season three if Rumplestiltskin and Belle should still be on this list. I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt for being so likable through two seasons and hope that season three was not an indication of where I'm headed with them. If they did come off this list, they would be replaced with Kathryn Nolan/Abigail and Dr. Archie Hopper/Jiminy Cricket. The other reason I didn't go ahead and switch them out is because I'm not sure I could find one - much less three - retellings for King Midas' Daughter and/or Jiminy Cricket.

Rewatching season one, I discovered something that surprises me not at all: I miss Graham.

Ruby and Regina are in a constant flux over which one is my favorite. On the episodes that Ruby is actually on, it's her. All the rest are Regina. Jefferson has been my favorite of the guys since he was introduced, though Hook runs a close second.

Of these retellings, I've read only three. I would love to read more as some of these books sound really good.


Who are your favorites from Once? Want to give me any suggestions on retelling? Want to guess which one of these was the hardest to find retellings for? (Hint: It's the one I totally cheated on and gave you a manga for one of the books.)

Comments (6)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Hook is one of my favorite characters in Once. I think Peter Pan ranks up there as one of my favorite retellings --- the background they gave him and Rumpel were breathtaking :)
My recent post Sunday Post: April 12 & Zoo Extravaganza!
1 reply · active 518 weeks ago
Yeah, the whole Neverland story arc was absolutely amazing. Without a doubt, it was my favorite half-season of the show!
Ruby was a big favourite with my room mate and I. We were so upset that she wasn't in the show for long! Regina is probably both of our favourites now. Rumple used to be mine...but I feel like they did so many interesting things with his character that they...ran out of things to do. It's a shame because I love Robert Carlyle so much - he is FANTASTIC. But his character arc these days...not so good. I'm super done with the villains they have this season :-/. So my favourites currently on the show are definitely Regina and Hook (because HELLO HAVE YOU SEEN HIM?? Although I probably ship Swan Queen as much as I ship Captain Swan. I would be happy for either).

OH and Mulan!!! Man, I wish she was back on the show! They dropped this awesome bi story line on us...AND THEN ABANDONED US.
My recent post Series Review: Legend by Marie Lu
1 reply · active 517 weeks ago
Glad to know I'm not the only one that likes Ruby. She seriously needs more love because she's just awesome. And now I hear that she's not even a guest star in season four - really disappointing. Of the main group that we get to see pretty much every week now...Yeah, mine are probably Regina and Hook too. It's just that I got their story arc and then left (sometimes just a couple episodes, even.) Rumple was one of my favorites right from the start, but the whole 'dagger' thing towards the end of season three really upset me. So, I'll have to wait until I can watch season four to decide what, exactly, I think about him and Belle now. And - me being the girl that doesn't notice romance until I am slapped over the head with it - was totally befuddled with the whole Mulan/Aurora thing. But I loved the idea so much more than anything to do with Phillip because he's so...princely and boring. Of course, being network tv, we couldn't actually have a homosexual relationship (Whedon not withstanding, but...meh). Which is really a shame because rewatching season one, I am amazed at how much chemistry Emma and Regina have.
Yes! I've kinda given up on this show because it seems to just revolve around the same people and story lines now, but I loved it in the beginning when we were discovering new characters and backstories, and I LOVED Ruby. Where has she gone to?
My recent post Interview & Giveaway: Lindsay Smith, author of SKANDAL | blog tour
1 reply · active 517 weeks ago
I think that was my problem with the second half of season three. If you've seen it, you'll probably know why the plotline reminded me so strongly of season one. (As spoiler free as I can make it.) Really, rewatching season one, I remember one of my favorite things about the show was how we were always dealing with someone new. Now it just seems like they're introducing people in favor of ignoring the original cast - and not even giving those new characters much attention. (I think they started following only a certain group at least at the beginning of season three, but I LOVE the Neverland story so I won't complain.)

Post a new comment

Comments by